National Fair Learning InitiativeAdvocacy built by technology

Blog · · Sarah Coard

They Said It Was Behavior. I Knew It Was More: How I Fought for My Son’s Right to an Independent Educational Assessment

My son Jack was nine years old the first time a school told me he had a “behavior problem.”

He was the kid who cried over homework. Who snapped his pencil in half during writing assignments. Who came home every single day slumped against the car door, exhausted in a way no third-grader should be. His teacher described him as “inattentive” and “avoidant.” The school psychologist suggested ADHD. And before I fully understood what was happening, Jack had a Behavior Intervention Plan = a BIP – designed to address what they called his “refusal behaviors” in class.

Nobody once asked why he was refusing.

It took two more years, a private evaluation, and a formal request for an Independent Educational Evaluation before anyone used the words that actually explained my son: dyslexia and dysgraphia. Two Specific Learning Disabilities that the school had never once evaluated him for – not because they couldn’t, but because they kept pointing at his behavior instead.

If you’re reading this because something doesn’t add up about your own child’s school experience, please keep reading.

The BIP That Missed the Point

A Behavior Intervention Plan is a document that identifies a student’s “challenging behaviors” and outlines strategies to reduce them. In theory, BIPs can be helpful tools — particularly for students whose behaviors are rooted in genuine emotional or developmental needs.

But here’s what I didn’t know at the time: a BIP is not an evaluation. It doesn’t dig into why a child is struggling. And when a school rushes to manage behavior without first investigating its root cause, children with unidentified learning disabilities can spend years being disciplined for symptoms that were never their fault.

Jack wasn’t refusing to write because he was defiant. He was refusing because writing was genuinely, physically, cognitively painful for him. His brain processes written language differently. Every letter he put on paper cost him enormous effort. Of course he avoided it. Wouldn’t you?

The BIP rewarded him with sticker charts for “complying” with writing tasks. It never once addressed the underlying reason those tasks were so hard.

→ Important distinction: Avoidance and refusal in children are often symptoms of an unmet need, not character flaws. A BIP that doesn’t address root causes can mask a learning disability for years.

Why the School Wouldn’t Evaluate for a Specific Learning Disability

I asked – more than once – whether Jack could be tested for a learning disability. I’d done enough late-night research to know that dyslexia and dysgraphia were real, diagnosable conditions covered under IDEA. I knew that schools were legally required to evaluate if there was reason to suspect a disability.

The responses I got ranged from “His reading scores aren’t low enough to qualify” to “We feel the current interventions are sufficient” to, once, a very gentle suggestion that I consider whether Jack’s home environment might be contributing to his stress.

What I didn’t know then – and know now – is that a child doesn’t have to be failing to have a learning disability. Many students with dyslexia and dysgraphia are described as “bright but struggling.” They develop coping strategies that keep their grades in a passing range while costing them enormous energy. The gap between their potential and their output is the real indicator – and standardized scores alone often miss it completely.

The school wasn’t lying to me. But they were working within a framework that wasn’t built to find Jack’s disabilities. And because they never looked, they never found them.

What Is an Independent Educational Evaluation?

An Independent Educational Evaluation (IEE) is an assessment of your child conducted by a qualified professional who is not employed by your school district. Under the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), parents have the legal right to request an IEE at public expense if they disagree with the evaluation performed — or in our case, not performed — by the school.

That last part is worth emphasizing: you don’t have to accept a school’s refusal to evaluate as the final word. If you believe your child has a disability the school hasn’t identified, you can push back — in writing, with legal backing.

→ Key takeaway: An IEE gives you a second opinion from a professional of your choosing, not the school’s — and in many cases, the school district is required to pay for it.

Why Families Request an IEE: Common Reasons

Our situation isn’t unusual. Here are the most common reasons families pursue an IEE:

  • The school evaluated your child but you disagree with the results or conclusions.
  • The school refused to evaluate for a specific disability, like a Specific Learning Disability (SLD), dyslexia, or dysgraphia.
  • Your child received a BIP or behavioral intervention without any evaluation for an underlying learning or developmental disability.
  • The school’s evaluation was incomplete – it tested some areas but not others relevant to your child’s struggles.
  • A private clinician identified a condition the school’s report didn’t address or acknowledge.
  • You believe the evaluator lacked specialized expertise in the area of concern (e.g., dyslexia-specific assessment tools were not used).
  • The evaluation didn’t account for your child’s cultural background, home language, or trauma history.

How to Request an IEE: Step by Step

Step 1: Put Your Request in Writing

Verbal conversations don’t create paper trails. Send a written letter or email to your child’s special education coordinator or school principal. State clearly that you disagree with the district’s evaluation — or that the district failed to conduct an evaluation you believe was warranted — and that you are requesting an IEE at public expense. Keep copies of everything.

→ Sample language: “I am writing to formally request an Independent Educational Evaluation for my child, [Name], at public expense. I disagree with the district’s evaluation dated [date] / I believe the district failed to evaluate my child for a Specific Learning Disability despite my repeated requests. I am requesting a comprehensive evaluation that includes assessment for dyslexia and dysgraphia.”

Step 2: Know the School’s Obligations

Once you submit your request, the school district must respond promptly. They have two options: agree to fund the IEE, or file for a due process hearing to defend their evaluation. If they do neither in a timely manner, they may be in violation of your child’s rights under IDEA.

Step 3: Understand the Criteria

The school may provide a list of qualified evaluators and criteria around geography and cost. You are not required to use their list, but the evaluator you choose must meet the same professional qualifications as the district’s evaluator. If cost is a barrier, you can negotiate or request exceptions.

Step 4: Choose the Right Evaluator

For suspected dyslexia and dysgraphia, look specifically for a licensed educational psychologist or neuropsychologist with experience in Specific Learning Disabilities and who uses research-validated, dyslexia-specific assessment tools. Ask whether they have experience writing evaluations that are used in IEP meetings. This matters.

I found our evaluator through a local dyslexia advocacy network. She spent two full days with Jack, reviewed his school records, observed him in his classroom, and interviewed his teachers. She used tools the school had never considered. Her report was 52 pages long. The school’s had been six.

Step 5: Use the Results

The school must consider the IEE results when making decisions about your child’s education. Bring the report to an IEP meeting and ask, point by point, how each finding and recommendation will be incorporated into your child’s plan. You are allowed to ask for a new IEP meeting specifically to discuss the IEE results.

What Changed for Jack

The independent evaluator confirmed what I had known in my bones for years. Jack had dyslexia — a phonological processing deficit that made decoding written words genuinely difficult — and dysgraphia, which affected his ability to translate his thoughts into written language. Both are Specific Learning Disabilities. Both are covered under IDEA. Both had been sitting there, undiagnosed, while the school managed his “behaviors.”

The BIP was discontinued. In its place, Jack received specialized, structured literacy instruction using an Orton-Gillingham based approach, occupational therapy for his writing, extended time on assessments, and the option to demonstrate his knowledge verbally or through typed responses.

Jack is twenty-one now. He still works hard — dyslexia and dysgraphia don’t just disappear — but he understands himself. He advocates for his own accommodations in college. He talks openly about how he learns. He knows his brain is wired differently, not broken. And when he looks back at those early years, he isn’t angry — he’s determined to make sure other kids don’t lose the same time he did.

The IEE didn’t fix everything overnight. But it replaced a narrative about his behavior with the truth about his learning. That made all the difference.

You Are Your Child’s Best Advocate

If your child has been labeled as a “behavior problem,” ask why. If they have a BIP but have never been evaluated for a learning disability, ask why. If you’ve requested testing and been turned down, ask why — and then ask again, in writing.

You are not being difficult. You are doing your job.

Knowing your rights under IDEA — including the right to request an IEE — is one of the most powerful tools available to you. Don’t wait until your child has spent years in the wrong intervention. Trust what you see at home, at the kitchen table, in the car on the way home from school.

You don’t have to accept the first answer.

Resources

  • Wrightslaw.com — plain-language explanations of special education law, including IEE rights
  • Your state’s Parent Training and Information (PTI) Center — find yours at parentcenterhub.org
  • COPAA (Council of Parent Attorneys and Advocates) — copaa.org
  • International Dyslexia Association — dyslexiaida.org, including a state-by-state resource directory
  • National Fair Learning Initiative — resources, advocacy, and community support for families navigating special education

This post shares one family’s experience and general information. It is not legal advice. For help with your child’s situation, talk with a special education advocate or attorney, or your state’s Parent Training and Information Center.

← All blog posts