
If you’re anything like me—on a mission to make sure your child learns to read with both confidence and skill—you’ve probably encountered Lucy Calkins and her popular Units of Study. Her approach, rooted in encouraging creativity, choice, and a love of literature, has shaped countless classrooms. But lately, I’ve been asking the same hard question: where’s the phonics?
Calkins’ method celebrates students picking their own books, crafting written responses, and using reading strategies like predicting or summarizing. On paper, it sounds ideal. We want our kids to love reading, right? But in practice, a critical piece was missing: explicit, systematic phonics instruction. Phonics isn’t optional—it’s how children decode words. This is especially true for kids with IEPs, dyslexia, or language delays.
Thanks to growing scrutiny, The New York Times published a revealing article in May 2022, noting that Calkins had been forced into “a major retreat,” with her curriculum “now embracing phonics and the science of reading.” But the Times and advocates pointed out that adding phonics reactivity isn’t enough—for many critics, it comes too late and feels incomplete nypost.com+11en.wikipedia.org+11theatlantic.com+11.
This criticism isn’t just from opinion writers—it’s grounded in research: The science of reading stresses that for many students, especially those who struggle, learning phonics systematically and early is essential. Without it, decoding becomes guesswork, leading to frustration and losing confidence . On the flip side, Calkins’ updates in 2022 felt to some like “patchwork”—more like lip service than full reform .
When reading instruction skips structured phonics, it becomes an equity issue. Students with learning differences are most at risk—they need explicit, predictable instruction to unlock reading. Without it, they often rely on pictures or guesswork, and can end up labeled as unmotivated when really, the method just didn’t meet their needs.
That’s why this matters so much for families like ours. Whether at the IEP table or team conferences, it’s completely valid to ask: How does the reading curriculum teach phonics? What structured approaches are in place for decoding? There are programs out there built on science—Orton-Gillingham, Wilson, structured literacy models—that should be part of this conversation.
I still appreciate what Lucy Calkins brought to literacy—namely, voice, creativity, and joy. But reading is more than enjoyment; it’s access. And that access begins with decoding, sound by sound—even for our most imaginative readers.
NFLI.ORG